Book four in the Elena Standish historical mystery series, A TRUTH TO LIE FOR is another navel-gazing novel in this new WWII series by Anne Perry.  Over the decades, Perry has become less concerned with the murder mysteries and instead more and more concerned with grappling with how individuals decide what is right and wrong, and the moral costs it takes to stand up for one’s convictions.  This can be a remarkable topic if done well, but Perry’s books tend to leave me feeling bludgeoned by her characters’ moral ponderings.  I have taken a break from her books for about five years because of this, and found upon returning to Perry’s writing that she has not increased her finesse in dealing with this topic.

Set in 1934, photographer and spy Elena Standish is sent by MI6 to smuggle two germ warfare scientists out of prewar Germany.  Elena contacts an American Jew who is a war correspondent in Berlin, whom she worked with as a spy previously.  The interplay between Elena and her friend is one of the best parts of the book.  Their spycraft seems remarkably juvenile, but perhaps in this earlier era, no real intelligence savvy was required?!  Elena’s job also fizzles out rapidly, contributing to the sense of flatness of the story.

I was curious how Perry was going to make her primary German Gestapo protagonist a sympathetic character.  Kudos to her, she does manage to pull this off nicely.  Watching this Gestapo officer tenderly interact with his family is the second enjoyable part of this novel.  Hitler and other German military leaders are, of course, portrayed as conniving and evil monsters, with a fairly heavy-handed handling of most of the German characters.  The English characters are not particularly nuanced either, and the cast is insipid overall.

Perry’s early works were so vivid and captured my imagination so well that I keep hoping for a spark of her early brilliance.  Unfortunately, A TRUTH TO LIE FOR is another lackluster Perry historical mystery novel with too much repetitive introspection and not enough action. 

Book Summary