This lengthy, almost epic, novel begins with a five year old girl, Dolly, hiding in a small hut with her mom as a revolution is swelling, fought and brutally put down. The Caribbean island of Montserrat is only the first setting for the true story of an ISLAND QUEEN. Dorothy Kirwan Thomas is next shown to us as a mature, wealthy lady, sipping from the best cups while she arranges to have her granddaughter schooled in England.

The daughter of an often absent Irish planter and a slave mother, Dolly learned fast about hard work. She didn’t have to labour in the harsh sugarcane plantation, but women had to work around houses and that brought her to the attention of her new master, John Coseveldt Cells. The accepted style of living was that the men had a family in Europe and another, unacknowledged, family in the West Indies. The eighteenth century shows us changes of colonial rulers, from French to Dutch to British, and Dolly could not depend on any man. A cruel, resentful half-brother Nicholas caused her to flee with her younger sister to Demerara, another sugar plantation.

I enjoy seeing the ordinary lives of the women; milliners, market stall holders, embroiderers and pot makers. They were able to earn, so they might hope to buy their freedom one day. We are shown the process, written documents, legal witnesses of standing, agreement of the fee, and the fact that Dolly had to prove she was spending her own money, not a loan – as the loaner of money would then own the person she was trying to free. The price was called manumission, but the slaves spoke of it as paying their ransom. Dolly had to develop proper businesses, starting with trading handmade goods and moving on to training domestic staff, because her family kept increasing, and she wanted to free everyone, including her mother. I have to wonder why nobody else was contributing, as that would have sped up the process.

We also visit Dominica and Barbados, revolution seldom far away during the eighteenth century. The turmoil of the West Indies is not often described in historical novels, but thanks to the real-life story of Dorothy Kirwan Thomas, as told by Vanessa Riley, I have a much better understanding. Even when she travels to England, as a business woman, Dolly is not able to stop fighting. The new overlords want to impose a tax on free women of colour, which just seems like resentment and greed to me. ISLAND QUEEN is fascinating reading and combines history, geography and personality in one great big bittersweet book.

Book Summary